Government’s plan to construct Roads of National Significance is a decade too late, says Canadian transport expert

Todd Litman, a transport expert visiting Wellington from the Victoria Transport Policy Institute, told a recent Motu Economic and Public Policy Research Centre seminar that the Government’s Roads of National Significance plans (which include the proposed Basin Reserve flyover) are a decade too late, because car use has peaked.

As reported by Wellington Scoop, Todd Litman said:

It’s time to employ a new urban planning model – one that favours accessibility over mobility – in order to meet increased consumer demand for walking, cycling and public transport.

Todd Litman went on to make some points that all New Zealand transport planners – and political parties – should be listening to. To again quote the Wellington Scoop report:

Decline in the auto industry is due to an ageing population, increases in fuel cost, urbanization, traffic and parking congestion, roading costs, changing consumer preferences, environmental and health concerns. He cited an Economist article from 22 September 2012 that went further, showing how the next generation is less inclined to get behind the wheel, and not even learning how to drive until later in life, if at all.

“Change in consumer demands is a terrific opportunity to save money and satisfy people’s demand for walking, biking, and public transport,” he added. “Unfortunately, the planning community is not taking advantage of this. We need to expand the scope of planning objectives. Formerly, it was focused on the speed of travel. I think there are a number of other objectives.”

The full presentation and audio from Todd Litman’s presentation have now been placed online by Motu. You can access them here:

http://www.motu.org.nz/building-capacity/past_public_policy_seminars#2013

We’d like to congratulate Motu for having the foresight to organise this seminar – and thank Todd Litman for bringing a reality check to a New Zealand transport planning scene that is dominated by outdated assumptions and business-as-usual thinking.

Whisper Who Dares: Is The NZTA The Government’s Enemy Within?

Many transport experts have weighed in on the short-sightedness, excessive cost and general all-around stupidity of the Government’s $10-billion-and-counting Roads of National Significance motorway-building programme. Now it’s time to meet the latest body to weigh in on the evils of the RONS – a disgruntled bunch called the New Zealand Transport Agency!

At a hearing in Queenstown over a plan to replace the current one-lane bridge over the Kawerau River with a two-lane bridge, the NZTA said that the Government’s Roads of National Significance programme is preventing it from upgrading important infrastructure in the regions as soon as it would like.

Senion project manager Phil Dowsett is quoted by Radio New Zealand as saying that the Roads of National Significance programme has pushed projects like this one to the bottom of the funding list.

There has been plenty of criticism from the regions of the way the RONS has sucked money out of local road maintenance – and if Phil Dowsett was a lone voice within NZTA, it would be easy to write him off as a maverick, or maybe just unusually forthright.

But from what we’re hearing, he is far from a lone voice. In reaction to our recent criticism of NZTA – criticism we think is richly justified by the agency’s public actions and statements – we’ve heard that, behind the scenes, a number of NZTA staff members are all too aware of the deficiencies of the Basin Reserve flyover project, but feel constrained by their position from saying so.

Sometimes, in these situations, word has a way of getting out. If you hear something of interest, please email us at stoptheflyover@gmail.com, or come up and talk to us at forthcoming public events.